92 points
Catoctin Creek Roundstone Rye Cask Strength 60%
The nose offers fresh grains but is also fruity, with jammy notes of grape and blueberry, sweet citrus aromas of lemon meringue and key lime pie, and rich mocha and cocoa powder. Creamy on the palate and lightly fruited with ripe blackberry, as well as cinnamon-covered French toast and milk chocolate. A length finish offers notes similar to the palate, ending with pepper spice and dark fruit. A big, flavorful, loaded up whiskey.
Reviewed by: David Fleming (Winter 2021)