88 points
The Macallan Classic Cut (2017 Edition), 58.4%
Released exclusively for the U.S., this is the first bottling in an annual series celebrating what Macallan terms its “…unrivalled commitment to the mastery of wood and spirit.” Matured in oloroso sherry-seasoned American and European oak casks. Confident Christmas cake aromas, plus quite assertive oak. Honey, toffee, vanilla, nutmeg, ginger, and lively oak on the palate. Gingery wood notes in the medium-length finish.
Reviewed by: Gavin Smith (Summer 2018)
The nose is delicate, with a pleasant balance of fruit and confectionary sweetness, resembling caramel apples and candied orange, and touches of fresh herbs. The palate delivers gentle red fruit, cocoa, and nutty notes that suggest sherry, but the impression is generally soft and lacking in proof, with grilled fruits and some spice appearing on a modest finish. Ironically, it offers neither richness nor cacao.